The movie also ends slightly differently than the book. The movie stays so close to the book that the book reads like a script of the film, but with a different and in my opinion worse way of creating the ending. The writing wasnt quite as dense in the second half. Its a rare movie that actually i adored so much that i am going to hunt down a copy of the book tomorrow just to see the comparisons.
Atonement is neither a movie about salvation nor a great english period piece about pride and prejudice. The books epilogue reveals that this atonement process was to write the preceding novel itself. Mar 25, 2002 atonement by ian mcewan doubleday, 400 pp. I rented the movie last summer from netflix and as soon as the movie ended, i stared at the blank. All this elaborate application of the principle of atonement shows the comprehensiveness with which it was sought by. Atonement joe wrights 2002 feature film atonement, based on ian mcewans 2002 critically acclaimed novel of the same name, masterfully adapted for the screen by christopher hampton, is at its heart about language and its power. See more ideas about atonement, atonement movie, movie posters.
While anne was living in the annex she fell in love with peter. This theory speaks of christ on the cross as a perfect example of what kind of dedication followers of god must do, there is no connection to a. Jun 16, 2008 the movie stays so close to the book that the book reads like a script of the film, but with a different and in my opinion worse way of creating the ending. Atonement i usually make a point of not seeing a movie before i get a chance to read the book, but the opposite is true for my experience with mcewans atonement. The title of atonement cuts to a picture of an eccentric mansion.
Keira knightley plays cecelia, the oldest daughter of the manor house who. One can atone for a terrible deed by writing about it and changing the end and then, perhaps, by confessing to that fabrication later, as briony does on a tv interview show. Atonement summary from litcharts the creators of sparknotes. The films treatment of the epilogue does a much better job of making briony a sympathetic character, at least in my opinion.
Movie april 4, 2016 ian mcewans 2001 novel, atonement, tells the story of thirteen year old briony tallis a young british girl who with one false accusation completely dismantles lives and the relationship between her older sister cecilia and the love of her life, robbie. Atonement is a 2007 romantic war drama film directed by joe wright and starring. Aug 17, 2009 furthermore, in the book we see more povs than in the movie. I guess what i am trying to say is, the book is so much more complicated and thorough than the film, and i think because of that we miss so much of the books importance and themes. Aug 12, 20 the first was joe wrights 2007 adaptation of ian mcewans novel atonement. We start out at the tallis familys very upperclass english home in 1935, a few years before world war ii. Instead of briony having a monologue about everything thats happened with her writing and cecilia and robbie, the film sets the ending up as an interview with briony, which, in my opinion, was more effective. There are several key differences between the novel and the film. I previously wrote a short post about ian mcewans atonement. So yeah, yesterday, at about 10pm i was finishing the book, and i started to cry, and couldnt stop, all the last pages. With keira knightley, james mcavoy, brenda blethyn, saoirse ronan. Differences between the book atonement and the movie vary from the more indepth understanding of the characters and point of views in the book that arent in the movie to the wry sense of humor.
The book is about the power of words, the blurry line between fantasy and truth, and the consequence of not understanding the meaning of words or sexual attraction. Furthermore, in the book we see more povs than in the movie. After i saw the movie, i went back and skimmed the rest of the book to contrast and compare. She describes going to a library to donate her correspondence with corporal nettleused to write this bookand afterwards attends a birthday. Mcewans style is verbose and archaic which contributes to the mood and tone of the story and his attention to detail is what generated a profound piece of literature that atonement came to be. The description of what happened at dunkirk is especially moving. The kite runner and atonement compared the blog of rio akasaka. It is slow reading at first that picks up after the first third.
Atonement, which stars james mcavoy t here are moments delirious, languorous, romantic moments when this film appears to have the lineaments of a. Atonement opens in 1935, at a stately manor in the english countryside. Film is a column comparing books to the film adaptations they spawn, often discussing them on a plotpointbyplotpoint basis. Yesterday i saw the film version, which for the most part renders the book.
Well, i havent watched the film, but now that i read the book, i cannot wait to see the film. There is an oddly postmodern twist to the notion of atonement in this movie and presumably in the book as well. Atonement begins on joyous gossamer wings, and descends into an abyss of tragedy and loss. Atonement book and movie comparison essay a little gies, mr. The first was joe wrights 2007 adaptation of ian mcewans novel atonement.
There is a contrast between black and white with the wording atonement shot 2. Joe wrights oscar winning adaptation of ian mcewans ohso literary novel atonement, was the first 15 i saw at the. I enjoyed wrights atonement more than luhrmanns gatsby for a host of reasons1, but one of the main ones is that atonement works so much better as an adaptation of its. Differences between atonement the book and movie answers. Set in three time periods, 1935 england, second world war england and france, and presentday england, it covers an upperclass girls halfinnocent mistake that ruins lives, her adulthood in the shadow of that mistake, and a reflection on the nature of writing. The book is also wonderful, but the visuals of the film are stupendous.
Atonement and in the lake of the woods are both metafictional works. Its opening scenes in an english country house between the wars are like a dream of elegance, and then a yearold girl sees something she misunderstands, tells a lie and destroys all possibility of happiness in three lives, including her own. Atonement is a 2007 romantic war drama film directed by joe wright and based on ian mcewan s 2001 novel of the same name. Atonement by ian mcewan 2007, paperback, movie tiein for. Atonement does not feel, at first, like a book by mcewan. Atonement is an unusual movie, in fact its fair to say that i have never seen anything quite like it. The character has the same name in both the book and the movie. The kite runner compared to atonement by gillian sherman on. Atonement study guide contains a biography of ian mcewan, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis.
In one sense, atonement is a book about misreading situations and the consequences this can have. All eight people lived in complete silence every day because the factory workers below might hear them. Throughout the credits there is the sound of a type writer, this again suggest that a story is going to be told. Find books like atonement from the worlds largest community of readers. We compare ian mcewans atonement to its cinematic adaptation, a film that stars keira knightley and james mcavoy. Sep 06, 2007 atonement, which stars james mcavoy t here are moments delirious, languorous, romantic moments when this film appears to have the lineaments of a classic. Atonement is a little more than midway up the mountain on the shmoop toughometer. What are some differences between the book atonement and the. Yesterday i finished the book atonement by ian mcewan, you know the movie i tried to recommend you, the one with keira knightly. Sep 08, 2014 this feature is not available right now. The mansion is a exact replica of brionys actual house. The churn in ian mcewans atonement is missing on the screen.
The house in part one of atonement is described as nothing more than an artificial island in an artificial lake29, being built in an older style despite being a newer house. Atonement is a 2001 british metafiction novel written by ian mcewan. Fledgling writer briony tallis, as a thirteenyearold, irrevocably changes the course of several lives when she accuses her older sisters lover of a crime he did not commit. Rather, it is a somewhat toned down version of lady chatterlys lover. She has just been diagnosed with irreversible dementia. Featuring deft performances from james macavoy and keira knightley, its a successful adaptation of ian mcewan. Koophuis and ellie vossen, former employees of otto, aided the eight people and helped to protect them. The film allows her to tell the interviewer, and by extension, both her readers and the audience, about her role as the author of atonement, while the novel has her admitting her fabrications only to her own writing. Engage your students during remote learning with video readalouds. The novel has a certain wry sense of humor that the film almost completely lacks. Identify episodes of misconception from the book and discuss what the says about the human condition to invent story in order to make sense, or place order, into an otherwise chaotic world. The book was a bestseller, and its got a lot of the things youd expect in a bestsellera plot that bangs along, a great love story, action, drama, excitement, and a writing style that can be both clear and just literary enough to thump you on the head. Jun 20, 2011 when critiquing the setting of a movie, the last thing you want to do is compare it to that of a book.
The kite runner compared to atonement by gillian sherman on prezi. The churn in ian mcewans atonement is missing on the screen joe wrights movie version does boast of a superb performance by saoirse ronan. Instead of the expected sharpness of focus, the first 70 or so pages are a lengthy summary of. This post will mostly focus on comparing the book and movie. I guess what i am trying to say is, the book is so much more complicated and thorough than the film, and i think because of that we miss so much of the book s importance and themes. The film stars james mcavoy, keira knightley, saoirse ronan, romola garai, benedict cumberbatch, and vanessa redgrave, and chronicles a crime and its consequences over the course of six decades, beginning in the 1930s. There is more background, explanation, everyones opinions and feelings are perfectly shown and understood. Its interesting to observe similarities between movies, and while common themes as seen before like between the illusionist and the prestige are classic examples, there are more subtle approaches to movie plots that id like to discuss, highlighting the presence of it in two recent releases, the kite runner and atonement. In essence, she is the author and the story is told through her eyes, although somewhat removed see major themes for more on this point. The novel, as in most cases, was more in depth than the movie was, understandably.
I wont lie, the first time i heard of the novel was. And then some of it doesnt, which can get the plot even more tangled. The beautiful film adaptation of atonement follows novelist ian mcewans characters into the carnage of world war ii. The story delves into the mind of a year old girl and her immature,selfish,shortsighted, and selfmotivating mindset that provoked her to inappropriately misreport her viewing of an eventthe result of which destroyed much of the lives of two people. When the story begins, briony is years old although, i have to say some pages have her at 12 and others at 11, but for the most part, it is determined she is. Film is a column comparing books to the film adaptations they spawn, often discussing them on a. Jan 17, 2008 the kite runner and atonement compared.
Free atonement papers, essays, and research papers. We compare ian mcewans atonement to its cinematic adaptation, a film that stars keira knightley and james mcavoy movie feature 7 years ian mcewan has been hailed as one of the most promising british writers of a generation, which is why perhaps his most recognisable title atonement was adapted for the big screen in 2007. Theories of the atonement erickson 1998 says there are a few theories on the atonement depending on how your read certain scripture, the theories are as follows. But like mcewan, the filmmakers are less concerned with bombs than with the deceptive power of words, especially in the act of telling storiesstories like the book, or the movie, which adds a level of artifice in being a story based on a story. While the house and grounds of the estate used in atonement movie are beautiful and fit with the theme of the book, the details of the book just cannot be equaled. The book is good, but i felt i was spoilt by the utterly beautiful film and so could not appreciate it. The second was baz luhrmanns adaptation of the great gatsby that came out earlier this year. When critiquing the setting of a movie, the last thing you want to do is compare it to that of a book. Atonement features strong performances, brilliant cinematography, and a unique score. Instead of briony having a monologue about everything thats happened with her writing and cecilia and robbie, the film sets the ending up as an interview with briony, which, in my opinion, was more effective than briony just rambling on at the end of the novel. The book is quite different than the film in some areas, but not significantly.
608 383 59 443 611 513 1241 136 264 548 633 480 734 462 1257 1376 1354 264 169 489 1078 1206 1470 1373 607 810 638 182 666 677 1085 1156 590 1330 915 330 143